While there have been several films about the 26/11 Mumbai terrorist attacks, Bharat Bhhagya Viddhaata tells the story that most filmmakers have missed. Instead of focusing on commandos, police officers or high-profile sites, director Manoj Tapadia looks to ordinary nurses, doctors and hospital personnel at Cama Hospital who found themselves amidst extraordinary events on one of the darkest nights in India’s history.
The result is a movie that is respectful and engaging emotionally, though it sometimes struggles with pacing.
Set during the horrific events of November 26, 2008, Bharat Bhhagya Viddhaata tells the tale of workers from the healthcare profession trying to protect vulnerable patients while the terror unfolds all around them. Geeta Madhav (played by actress Kangana Ranaut) is the focal point of the story. She is a nurse who must confront her own fears and rise above them when the situation calls for bravery. The film does not create a superhuman hero out of her and simply shows her as a normal person carrying out their responsibilities under impossible circumstances, which supports the way the story is told in this film.
The sincerity of Bharat Bhhagya Viddhaata stands out as one of its most significant attributes. In a current-day age where many dramatizations attempt to exaggerate emotions, by way of loud speeches and excessive patriotic dialogue, Tapadia has crafted a film that is uncharacteristically subdued. He fully understands that the strength of the film lies in the humanity of the characters, as evidenced by their fearful expressions, difficult choices, and the quiet resolve with which they continue their work.
Tapadia deserves recognition as the director for being able to create tension throughout much of the film. Even in the absence of explosions and confrontations on screen, there remains a continual feeling of unresolved tension while watching in the hallways of the hospitals. The film does an excellent job of depicting life in an environment where making a wrong choice is often a matter of life or death. However, there are times in the film when the screenplay becomes unfocused and does not maintain a rhythmic momentum. Some of the scenes are repetitive and may have benefited from tighter editing.
Kangana Ranaut delivers one of her most controlled performances in recent years. She resists the temptation to dominate every scene and instead becomes part of the larger ensemble. Her portrayal of the character Geeta was executed so skillfully and convincingly that the audience could relate to both her strengths and vulnerabilities. There is an inner strength to her performance that matches perfectly with the tone of the film.
The rest of the ensemble cast also made major contributions. Even with limited opportunities to share the spotlight, Girija Oak and Smita Tambe made significant impressions through their performances in helping to reinforce the film’s theme that heroism is a collective endeavor, as opposed to one person’s accomplishment.
Visually, Bharat Bhhagya Viddhaata is not overly showy but does have a successfully achieved visual aesthetic that fulfills the film’s purpose. The cinematography focuses on realism with a preference for dimly lit environments, narrow spaces, and hand-held camera shots, which provides increased tension in the film. The hospital itself is used as another character in the film; it is normally a location associated with healing, but is portrayed as an alternate location conducive to survival. The camera focuses on the individuals who have been impacted by violence, and does not sensationalize the violence that takes place. This technique provides much of the film’s non-verbal emotional impact.
Bharat Bhhagya Viddhaata succeeds in knowing who the heroes are; it is not seeking to recreate a larger-than-life image or use cinematic spectacle as a vehicle to communicate its message. Rather, it presents its heroes as doctors, nurses, and support staff who provided assistance and support to others during a time when fear may have caused individuals not to provide assistance or support. While the film’s uneven pacing prevents it from becoming truly exceptional, its heartfelt storytelling, strong performances, and respectful treatment of real events make it a worthwhile watch.